Tuesday, 31 December 2013

New Year's Eve

Well, that's about it for 2013. It has been a hectic, frantic year with lots going on and all sorts of new discoveries and adventures. To all our dedicated readers, thank you for making 2013 our most successful and for all your positive and encouraging comments.

Today at the institute, we had a little celebration for the 100th anniversary of geophysical measurements (more on that tomorrow).

But tonight's "photograph" is a close-up of the inside of an HBA tile, shot at midnight in the depths of a polar night, with no moon, overcast skies and a complete power failure. The temperature outside is -15 (although those tiles keep it at a toasty -10 C inside them).

This photograph is intentionally black.
(Okay... so we made this one up.)

:-)

Thanks for 2013!

Best wishes for the new year!!

Monday, 30 December 2013

Unreal photographs

There are some stunning photographs of the aurora, wildlife and the Arctic landscape these days. Better cameras, more photographers and better knowledge help. And, sure enough, the opportunities to catch those stunning moments increase. With the Internet, these are readily distributed and reach a huge audience.

Sadly, however, there are a number of altered photographs out there, which distort our perception of reality. These photographs may not be intentionally altered to deceive, but the original captions, the original context and the original audience is lost as they are circulated about the web via a plethora of social media channels.

It is only by actually having been in these places and seen these things that a few of us have the perception to recognise such alterations. Like the old depictions of lions by northern Europeans in the medieval period, they are laughable if you know what a real lion actually looks like.

But we have this with many modern Arctic photographs. Sure, the quality of the alteration is sophisticated, but many who do not know better see this as reality... which it is not.

Allow me to give an example.

In the last week or so, there have been a very popular image doing the rounds of a polar bear in front of the aurora. Of course, the world has been "ooooh" and "aaaahh" and "what a beautiful photograph". Here is the first version that I saw, posted by Animal Planet (@MeetAnimals on Twitter)...


Posted on Twitter by @MeetAnimals

As an astronomer/geophysicist working in the Arctic, I'm used to seeing the northern lights. I also have done some astrophotography (both as an amateur and professionally). What immediately struck me about the image was the contrast in the lighting and the implied exposure-time requirements. Something didn't look right.

Because the Earth rotates, the sky appears to move. To get the stars to appear as pin-pricks, you need a relatively short focal-length on the camera, or you need to have a tracking platform, or you need a really big lens which  has huge light-gathering power. The lens for the star field was definitely wide-angle, as you can see part of Ursa Major at the top and the bright star Alpha Boötes (above and to the left of the bear's head). This puts the vertical field-of-view at about 60 degrees. At a quick guess, I'd estimate that would be a 28mm to 35mm lens. That's a fairly wide-angle lens.

So, to the bear...

For a wide angle lens, the bear doesn't seem right. It looks too "flat", meaning that it was taken with a long focal length telephoto lens. Not surprising... given that it is a bear! Then there is the exposure. The lighting levels are not consistent with what I know real aurora to look like. The diffuse "grey" light implies a uniform white light... probably an overcast day or similar.

Given the diffusion of the aurora, this would be a fairly long exposure to get those intensities. That also matches up with the star images. In fact, you you look carefully, there are stars down to Mag. 6.5... for example I can make out HIP 67103. This is below naked-eye visibility. The bear would have to be still for quite a while there.

While the photograph was not impossible (I could contrive a lens/lighting combination that might result in something like that), it seems HIGHLY unlikely. Too unlikely.

I was suspicious.

So, I started trying to find the original. What I wanted to know was the where/when that the photo was taken. Was it in the right place? Did the star patterns match? And... most importantly, what was the camera and lens? Knowing that would help clinch whether this was good photography or good photoshop.

Then, during my search, I found this...

Found via Internet search.

Same bear, but mirror image. And a different sky-scape. This one looks even more unlikely, in terms of exposure inconsistency, but the presence of the first image clinches it.

These are not real.

I checked the original site and, it most clearly states in the fine print that:

DIGITAL COMPOSITE: Aurora borealis swirls across the sky over a polar bear standing on a rock on the tundra. (composite of two images)

... which is great! They are making it quite clear that this is a composite image, which is perfectly valid. That's art, after all.

So, the problem is in the "chinese whispers" that saw the image propagate across the Internet. With each step, it becomes more and more removed from the original and people start taking it at face value to the point where some are talking about nominating it for "photograph of the year".

By no means should one consider composites as problematic. But what is disturbing, is that those who propagate it fail to mention (or do not even know) that it is such an image. The result is a distorted perception of reality in the minds of many who do not have the background or experience to recognise it for what it is. This is a harmless example, but there are implications...

When you know a topic and you see the way that it is portrayed across the media (meaning Internet and other communication channels), you begin to wonder how thin and shallow must all the other things be that we see there and take for granted. Every news report. Every article. Every web post.

The key cornerstone of science is not facts or knowledge, but critical thinking. Questioning and checking. Not knowing, but wanting to find out. And taking nothing at face value, but verifying. When we at least know something, we are given the tool to recognise things and know where to direct our interrogation.

In the meantime, we need to be wary...


... there are a lot of polar bears out there!







References
  • Image 1 -- http://photos.alaskaphotographics.com/
  • Image 2 -- http://photos.alaskaphotographics.com/

Sunday, 29 December 2013

Beyond the wire

Today's icy photograph is taken on the landscape beyond the KAIRA reindeer fence.

The world beyond the wire (Photo: D. McKay-Bukowski)

Saturday, 28 December 2013

RFI investigations

On Wednesday, we reported on some strange RFI (radio-frequency interference). Today we've a few more leads on our investigation.

The following aspects have been noted:
  • The events appear equally in both X- and Y-polarisations. 
  • The events last between 5 and 10 minutes. However, they are not always the same duration. 
  • The events are broadband, but seem to be stronger at some frequencies. This is not linear nor monotonic across the different frequencies. 
  • The rise is generally quite gradual, although sometimes there is an initial step function to start. 
  • The end of the event is extremely abrupt.
During the observations, correlator files were being acquired. This allows us to check on the direction of the RFI by forming an all-sky image. The following is an example showing an RFI event.



It seems that the source is always the same direction (az = approx. 150 degrees) and is always on the horizon. Using the KAIRA landscape in Stellarium, we can check on this direction.



The beamsize at the frequency of the all-sky image above is approx. 8 degrees. This is not huge, but is sufficient to show that the source is unlikely to be Saana (there is a radio transition station on the mountain there at az=131).

However, at az=150, there are LOTS of potential sources: the customs (Tulli) station, IRIS, Retkeilykeskus, the village centre, the Biol.Asema, et al..

Investigations continue...


Friday, 27 December 2013

Snow driving

Normally, we show winter photographs during the daytime... well, er, at least during the midday twilight, for what it is worth. However, as you might imagine, much of the time is dark and snow and poor visibility. That can be tricky to photograph. However, today we've something that looks a bit more typical.

A more typical view of the KAIRA site in winter. (Photo: D. McKay-Bukowski)

Actually, on this particular occasion, we managed to get the vehicle stranded. The snow was soft and when we had trouble starting it, we over spun the wheels, which dug down and left the vehicle stranded on a mini-snow-hill.

It took about 3 hours to dig it out.     :-P

Thursday, 26 December 2013

Inari landscapes

Today we have one last photographs from the week of the Inverse Days 2013 conference. (It seems like yesterday... but also like an eternity ago!). We hadn't shown any photographs of the surrounding landscape, but today we have a chance to put that right.

Trees in the wilderness (Photo: V. Junttila)

A corner of Lake Inari (Photo: V. Junttila)

Scraggly branches... look carefully to see
the bird perched there (Photo: V. Junttila)

Gloaming behind the sparsely wooded hillsides. (Photo: V. Junttila)

Wednesday, 25 December 2013

Strange RFI

Today we've been working on a strange RFI (radio-frequency interference) problem. Inspired by Juha's recent investigations and wishing to resolve this problem so as to hopefully clean up our own data, we've gone back to start working on this problem again.

The first step is to actually understand what we have. Initially, the problem was noticed by Antti during some of this data reduction work on the riometry data that we've been taking. However, others have seen it as well in astronomy experiments. So far the problem has only showed up on the low-band antenna (LBA) array, but we're trawling data as this is being written so as to see if it occurs in higth-band data too.

The characteristic of this effect is a gentle rise in RF power, followed by a sudden drop. In order to carry out a full investigation, we need to capture one of these events under favourable conditions. This occurred during some Tsys calibration observations in November 2013.

Time series for one aerial for a small range of subbands.

In the first figure, the drops are due to changes in pointing direction, causing a momentary loss in power. The problems are the ones that rise up like serrated spikes (we refer to them as dragon's-teeth).

The nature of these is actually broad band, but not completely. They show up at several frequencies, but with a broad pattern at each. Olaf suggests that this might be due to the fact that there is a very high-rate time variation, which is something we'll need to investigate.

A 2D spectrum showing the multi-frequency nature of the RFI.
Note also the large areas of shortwave radio interference.

In any case, this is a very puzzling phenomena. But one which we are determined to figure out. Thanks to Menno, Antti, Juha, Olaf and Richard for helping out!